HACCP vs HARPC: Key Differences and Which Applies to Your Food Facility
Clear comparison of HACCP (Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points) and HARPC (Hazard Analysis and Risk-Based Preventive Controls), covering applicable scenarios, documentation requirements, and PCQI responsibilities.
HACCP is the traditional food safety system methodology, used in GFSI-recognized schemes and many countries' food regulations. HARPC is the new requirement created by FSMA 21 CFR Part 117, forming the core of preventive controls plans. Key difference: HARPC has a broader scope (including allergen controls, sanitation, supply chain programs, and recall plans), requires PCQI signature, and emphasizes risk-based decision-making beyond just CCPs. For the US market, HARPC compliance is required; for other markets, HACCP is typically sufficient.
1. Applicability & Scope
This guide is for food factories preparing to export to the US or seeking GFSI certification, and food safety personnel wanting to understand the regulatory and certification positioning of HACCP and HARPC. Does not apply to businesses exporting only to China or other markets without HARPC requirements (for those markets, traditional HACCP is sufficient).
2. Regulatory Basis & Standards
HACCP is based on Codex Alimentarius HACCP principles and application guidelines. HARPC is based on 21 CFR Part 117, issued by FDA under FSMA. Codex HACCP is the common foundation for GFSI-recognized schemes (BRCGS, FSSC 22000, SQF, IFS), but each scheme has different additional requirements beyond CCPs.
3. HACCP vs HARPC Core Comparison
Key comparison dimensions: Hazard scope (HACCP traditionally focuses on biological/chemical/physical hazards; HARPC adds radiological and economically motivated adulteration); Control types (HACCP focuses on CCPs; HARPC adds allergen controls, sanitation, supply chain programs, and recall plans as preventive control categories); Authorized personnel (HACCP has no mandatory PCQI requirement; HARPC mandates PCQI signature); Evidence approach (HACCP generally requires validation; HARPC also requires monitoring records and reanalysis schedules).
4. Required Documents Checklist
Whether HACCP or HARPC, the following are fundamental elements of a food safety plan document:
- Written hazard analysis: hazard identification and assessment records for all products and process steps
- Preventive measures (CCPs or preventive controls): with limits, monitoring frequency, corrective actions, and verification methods
- Allergen management procedures (mandatory for HARPC, also typically required by GFSI)
- Sanitation control procedures and records (cleaning validation, sanitization effectiveness assessment)
- Supply chain program (approved supplier list, audit records, and incoming material verification)
5. How QTC Can Support
QTC provides HACCP and HARPC documentation system coaching, hazard analysis technical support, food safety plan drafting assistance, and PCQI resource coordination. The project organizes CCP or preventive controls, monitoring records, corrective actions, and verification evidence into a structure that is easier for auditors and buyers to review.
6. Project Timeline & Process
Coaching process: 1. Target market and certification requirement confirmation → 2. Existing HACCP plan gap analysis → 3. HARPC additional requirement supplementation (if exporting to US) → 4. Hazard analysis update and preventive control additions → 5. Staff training → 6. System validation and records trial run → 7. Mock audit (GFSI or FDA scenario).
7. Official Sources & Last Modified
Sources: Codex Alimentarius HACCP Principles (fao.org/fao-who-codexalimentarius); 21 CFR Part 117 (ecfr.gov); FDA FSMA preventive controls rule explanatory materials. Content verified as of June 2026.
8. Professional Review Team Profile
Reviewed by QTC's food safety system coaching expert team, with GFSI-recognized scheme internal auditor qualifications and FDA FSMA compliance coaching experience.
FAQ
For a factory already with HACCP, what extra work is needed to upgrade to HARPC?+
Key additions: 1. Expand hazard analysis to identify economically motivated adulteration risks; 2. Add allergen controls as an independent preventive control category (with monitoring and corrective action records); 3. Define a supply chain program (approved suppliers and incoming verification); 4. Develop a written recall plan; 5. Have a PCQI-qualified person sign the food safety plan.
Next steps
If this topic applies to your product, facility, or supply chain requirement, start by confirming the target market, customer-required standard, existing documents, audit history, and expected timeline.
